How do I choose an AI agency? What to ask and the warning signs

Before you hire an AI agency, get one task scoped in writing: what the system does, what it never does, what it answers from and who gets the cases it cannot handle. Then ask how it is tested, what it costs to run each month and who pays, and what you keep if you leave. Start with a small first build before any long contract.

Walk away from promises of guaranteed income or results, from “AI that runs your business on autopilot” or “replaces your staff”, and from any offer with no written scope and no terms on data and ownership. The US Federal Trade Commission has taken companies to court over claims like these.

This guide is written by Betterlane, an AI agency. The same questions apply to us.

Updated Nov 16, 2026

How it works

  1. Name one task first

    Pick the task that costs your team the most time or loses you the most customers: missed calls, slow replies, booking, a form someone retypes. An agency that starts from a list of AI features, instead of your task, is selling what it has.

  2. Ask for a written scope: what it does and never does

    One page is enough. What the system answers or does, in which channel, during which hours, and what it must never do: quote a price it was not given, promise a date, give medical or legal advice. If it is not written, you cannot check it, and nobody can say whether it works.

  3. Ask what it answers from

    A good assistant answers only from information you gave and approved: services, prices, hours, policies. Ask what happens when a question is not covered. The right answer is that it says it does not know and passes the question on, not that it makes something up.

  4. Ask how it is tested

    Ask to see the test before launch: ordinary questions, odd ones, other languages, and questions it must refuse. Ask whether your team can try it before any customer does. An agency that cannot show how it tests is asking you to test it on your customers.

  5. Ask who gets the hand-off

    Complaints, refunds, emergencies, anything unusual or sensitive should reach a named person on your team with a summary, in a place they already read. Ask where that message lands and how fast someone sees it.

  6. Ask the monthly running costs, and who pays them

    Beyond the agency’s fee, a live system has running costs: the AI model, phone minutes, WhatsApp message fees, the software it connects to. Ask for each line, whether it sits on your account or theirs, and what happens to the bill if usage doubles.

  7. Ask what you keep if you leave

    Your phone number, WhatsApp account, calendar, CRM and customer data should stay in your accounts. Ask for the answers, rules and workflows to be handed over in a form someone else can use. If everything lives in the agency’s accounts, leaving means starting again.

  8. Start with a small first build

    Agree one flow, live in days or weeks, before a long contract. The US Small Business Administration gives small businesses the same advice for these tools: start small, test whether they add value, and have a person review what they produce.

  9. Check for the warning signs

    Guaranteed income or results, “autopilot”, a system that “replaces your staff”, no written scope, no data terms, pressure to sign a long contract today. In 2024 the FTC sued companies it says sold AI with promises of easy earnings and a “robot lawyer” that had not been tested. Those are the FTC’s allegations; the pattern is what to watch for.

What it costs to run

An agency’s fee depends on the task and is agreed before work starts; Betterlane does not publish prices on this page. Whoever you hire, ask for the running costs line by line, because they are billed by other companies and keep going after the build.

What we learned building it

How we work at Betterlane: our own practice, not a client result

We write the scope before we build
One page: what the first flow answers or does, what it never does, and who it hands to. Whether it works is judged against that page, not against a feeling.
It answers only from what the business approved
Services, prices, hours and policies come from the business. When a question is not covered, the assistant says so and passes it on.
A person gets anything unusual
Anything unusual, sensitive or outside the scope goes to a person on the business’s team, with a summary of the conversation.
The business keeps its accounts, numbers and data
We build on the business’s own number and accounts. The team tests it with real questions before it goes live.
The first flow is free and scoped in writing
It is built in a week. If it does not do what was scoped, the business pays nothing. If the business then decides to stop, we hand over its facts, answers, booking rules and a setup note.

When it is not worth it

  • If a tool you already pay for has the automation built in, turn that on first. Many booking, CRM and helpdesk tools do.
  • If the task happens a handful of times a week, a template reply or a checklist costs less than any system.
  • If you have someone in-house who builds automations and has the time, an agency adds cost without adding much.
  • If you cannot yet say what the right answer to your customers’ common questions is, write that down first. No agency can build an assistant that knows what you do not.

Betterlane is an AI agency: ask us these same questions about a first flow for your business.

See the service: AI automation agencyLet’s talk

Questions

Should I pay up front?

For a small first build, pay little or nothing until you have seen it work against the written scope. For larger work, tie payments to things you can check: a working flow, a test you watched, a hand-over. Be careful with large up-front fees for work nobody has scoped yet.

Is a freelancer better than an agency?

For one well-defined workflow you can maintain yourself, a good freelancer can be the better choice. An agency makes more sense when you want the scope, testing and upkeep after launch to be someone else’s job. Ask either one the same questions.

What should the contract say about data?

Whose accounts the data sits in, what the agency may do with it, which other companies process it, and what happens to it when you leave. Under the UK GDPR, a contract with a processor must say it acts only on your documented instructions and, at your choice, deletes or returns the personal data at the end. Brazil’s ANPD recommends a contract that sets the purpose, duration, types of data and responsibilities under the LGPD.

What if it stops working?

Ask before you sign: who watches the system, how you report a problem, how fast it is fixed, and whether fixes are included in the monthly fee. Models, prices and connected tools change, so someone has to own the upkeep.

Is a guarantee a good sign?

Only if it is specific and written. A guarantee of income, sales or “results” is a warning sign. A promise tied to a written scope you can check, with what happens if it is not met, is something you can hold an agency to.

Sources

All guides